Home/Customer Service

Billing Center

Pay on-line by credit or debit card.  Each company has the ability to accept your online payments at their website. If you receive your billing directly from the insurance company, they have a special billing department to answer all of your questions.  Phone numbers for each company are listed below.

Allstate Insurance Co. 800-255-7828
Allied Insurance Co. 800-282-1446
Auto-Owners Insurance Co. 800-288-8740 opt 4
Bristol West Insurance Co. 888-888-0080
Erie Insurance Company 800-458-0811
Foremost Insurance 800-532-4221
Hagerty Classic Car 877-922-9701
Hastings Mutual Insurance Co. 800-442-8277
Pekin Insurance Co. 800-332-0160
Progressive Insurance Co. 800-876-5581
State Auto Insurance Co. 800-444-9950

Sign In to Your Account

First Time User?

Create Your Account

Create an account to:

  • File Claims
  • Make Policy Changes
  • Request Auto ID Cards
  • Make Payments
  • Request Certificates

Pay By Check


– Claims
– Quotes
– Change Requests
– Make a Payment
– Request a certificate
– Request ID


Monday-Friday: 8:00am to 5:00pm
Saturday: 9:00am to 12:00pm
Sunday: Closed


823 N. Section Street
PO Box 406 Sullivan, IN 47882

800-489-4711 (toll free)
812-268-4711 (local)
812-268-3809 (fax)

Site designed by AGENCYEAGLE copyright 2016